A House in the Sky: A Memoir
4.6 4.6 out of 5 stars | 9,771 ratings
Price: 19.68
Last update: 01-10-2025
About this item
Amanda Lindhout reads her spectacularly dramatic memoir of a woman whose curiosity about the world led her from rural Canada to imperiled and dangerous countries on every continent, and then into 15 months of harrowing captivity in Somalia - a story of courage, resilience, and extraordinary grace.
At the age of 18, Amanda Lindhout moved from her hardscrabble Alberta hometown to the big city - Calgary - and worked as a cocktail waitress, saving her tips so she could travel the globe. As a child, she escaped a violent household by paging through National Geographic and imagining herself in its exotic locales. Now she would see those places for real. She backpacked through Latin America, Laos, Bangladesh, and India, and emboldened by each experience, went on to travel solo across Sudan, Syria, and Pakistan. In war-ridden Afghanistan and Iraq she carved out a fledgling career as a TV reporter. In August 2008, she traveled to Mogadishu, Somalia - "the most dangerous place on Earth" - to report on the fighting there. On her fourth day in the country, she and her photojournalist companion were abducted.
An astoundingly intimate and harrowing account of Lindhout's 15 months as a captive, A House in the Sky illuminates the psychology, motivations, and desperate extremism of her young guards and the men in charge of them. She is kept in chains, nearly starved, and subjected to unthinkable abuse. She survives by imagining herself in a "house in the sky", looking down at the woman shackled below, and finding strength and hope in the power of her own mind. Lindhout's decision, upon her release, to counter the violence she endured by founding an organization to help the Somali people rebuild their country through education is a wrenching testament to the capacity of the human spirit and an astonishing portrait of the power of compassion and forgiveness.
Top reviews from the United States
Reviewed in the United States on August 24, 2024
Then I started reading. I found I actually LIKED Amanda, envied her pursuing her travel dreams, her gutsiness in visiting South America, India, Pakistan, wherever the spirit moved her, with a backpack and not much else. Afghanistan, even. It isn't until about a third of the way in that we get to her travel to Somalia, and by then I "got" it, understood the way Amanda thought and what motivated her to go to such a place, ignoring the warnings.
I have to give a lot of credit to the co-writer, Sara Corbett, for skillfully weaving a tale that I did not want to put down, even though it went to some dark and scary places. There are horrors recounted here: coercion, rape, torture, hopes raised and dashed, and starvation, but they are so carefully handled it did not become overwhelming and make me want to put the book down. (Other readers may have a different experience.)
I liked the nuanced look at all the captors - some are a bit caricatured, with nicknames like Donald Trump or Romeo, but their vulnerabilities and suffering is explored, too.
I also have to give Amanda much credit for being willing to dig deep and bring the reader to those dark places; she doesn't gloss over them or portray herself out as some stoic prisoner, always in control of herself. She blew it, and her mistake not only hurt her, but her friend Nigel, and her family. While she acknowledges guilt, she has also learned from her experience and continues to reach out to the people of Somalia through a non-profit organization to help educate women and girls.
I'm not sure if "enjoyed" is the right word for my reading experience, but I found this to be an excellent and compelling story, well-told, and I highly recommend it.
Many people have commented on Amanda's naivete, but I'm more interested in her attraction to danger, what she refers to, late in the book, as a foolish sense of invincibility. Early chapters reveal a difficult, dysfunctional childhood, but we are left to make connections between that and her choices as a self-made freelance journalist learning on the fly.
As more and more horrors unfold on the page, I wonder when the narrator will reflect on those choices, but it comes in only 1-2 paragraphs late in the book, and more in the form of a rapid summary of personality traits and apologies and not as elaborated introspection. I'm sure that Amanda and Corbett (and the publisher) made conscious decisions about how much or little of that to include. Memoirs can't be all things to all people. Some of the best read more like novels than confessions or self-analyses, and that's to their credit.
Yes, Amanda suffered from naivete and maybe a bit of false invincibility, but she is certainly not the first person in her or his mid-twenties to surf among the sharks. I can certainly think of times when my own desire for adventure or a transcendent traveling experience blinded me to reality, but I can't imagine venturing blithely into one of the most dangerous places on earth--Mogadishu--after surviving Iraq and Afghanistan. I don't get it, but that's my projection, and the internet age has a way of making the world into a big backyard. Her return to Somalia also seems strange. I love the forgiveness and the creation of a foundation to fund educational opportunities for the women there, but it strikes me as more odd than brave or therapeutic to return to the belly of the beast, the site of extreme trauma. Again, that's my projection.
Back to the narrative itself, I have to say that the description of the escape into the mosque and the momentary rescue by the Somali woman is one of the most devastating sequences I have read or viewed in a movie. The sheer facts are moving enough, but the writing lifts those scenes from the page and drives them into our hearts.
Amanda was turned inside out during her ordeal in Somalia. Her bravery and understanding, her insight and forgiveness, makes me only hope I could be that good of a person. I wonder if any of her captors were brought to justice? Has she heard any news of the group and what they are doing? Prayers said for her, Nigel, and their loved ones.