Discipline Without Damage

4.4 | 366 ratings

Price: 18.53

Last update: 12-03-2024

About this item

In this easy-to-listen-to, science-based book, parents, caregivers, and adults of all kinds discover how discipline affects children’s development, why intervention should reinforce connection not separation, and why the disciplinary strategies that may have been used on us as children are not the ones that children really need. As a practicing child and family psychologist and advisor to the British Columbia ministry of children and families, Dr. Vanessa has seen it all, and she has navigated hundreds of tough situations with families. Drawing on scientific research and a wealth of clinical experience, she shows you how to put out the fire without dampening your child’s spirits; how to correct their behavior while emphasizing connection; and how to discipline without damage.

Jessica Waggoner

Great book

Reviewed in the United States on April 17, 2024

Informative and helpful book for gentle and intuitive parenting.

Acacia Jensen

Game changer for parenting

Reviewed in the United States on February 12, 2016

I couldn't put this book down once I started reading it. The tone, the heart of the author towards children and their families in the struggle to raise them well shines right through the pages, and it is full of love, understanding and guidance. Vanessa writes so well, her tone so positive and full of good illustrations of the concepts she is presenting. It is a book every parent should receive and read as soon as they have a baby. If you really absorb and take with an open heart what she is writing about, your family life will change for the better, you'll be a much happier mom (I speak from experience), and you'll see the world differently in relation to what your children need from you as they grow. I wish every parent in the world would read this book. It's a game changer. Hands down the best $12.00 I've spent in a very long time.

Amazon Customer

All great stuff. One plus I will say is that ...

Reviewed in the United States on March 28, 2016

I have mixed feelings about this book. As a whole, yes, it is helpful. I agree with a lot of the "big picture" ideas. The author is advocating attachment parenting, setting firm limits while allowing the child's reactions to those limits and putting a primary focus on spending quality time with the child and strengthening the child-parent emotional bond. All great stuff. One plus I will say is that compared to another, similar author I read (Laura Markham who wrote the forward in this book by the way) the scripts given in this book are shorter, more realistic when put into practice.
My major complaint - and it is major - is that TWICE in the book the author states that holding on to "a little" parental guilt is a good thing because this guilt will motivate you to push yourself to be the best parent you can be.
No. This offends me so much and I think it is quite contradictory coming from a professional who claims to be advocating AVOIDING making children feel shame or guilt. The argument makes no sense-- one is supposed to raise a child to not feel shame or guilt but one is supposed to feel guilty over parenting mistakes? Anyone who has tried to make a life change (losing weight, addiction, etc) knows that guilt doesn't work as a long term motivator. If you want to be a better parent, work on yourself because you want to feel better and you want to improve your family life and enjoy life more. If one has guilt it is because one hasn't forgiven oneself and that's an unhealthy way to live.
My minor complaint with this book is that it is at times overly wordy and gives too much information to use as action points. I'd have to make flashcards and memorize all these points. One part of the book had, I believe, nine "touchstones" that you are supposed to go through in a particular scenario. But a lot of parenting books are like that so it is a minor thing.
Overall, read this book but with a grain of salt, and ignore the advice to hold on to your guilt.

Alicia

The best parenting book I’ve read so far

Reviewed in the United States on September 19, 2023

I have a 9 year old boy who has behavioral issues and if you truly follow this book and your heart things will get easier. My boy now only plays games two nights a week, cleans up after himself and helps with dinner. It’s a golden book and I cherish it!!!!!

Wolfgang F.

Very theoretical,not that helpful

Reviewed in the United States on April 20, 2016

If you are already on board with a no punishment, no rewards way of parenting, then this book may not offer you much. I was hoping for some more specific examples. I know it is all about connection. I've read this from a dozen different authors. But, specific challenges and ideas to handle them are not included beyond the grocery store example, which we've got down already. What about when a child won't wash her hands when getting home from school, or delays bedtime, etc...This book was ok, but I'm on to the next one.....

Kat

Increased my patience level!

Reviewed in the United States on July 12, 2017

This book was so helpful. The emphasis on how emotional control develops was very helpful for increasing my patience level with my child. I also loaned a copy to a coworker - the way he had talked about one of his children, an adopted child, made me wince from the lack of understanding. He got back to me and told me how eye-opening it was and how it really changed how they viewed some of their child's behaviors differently now.
It isn't perfect. It is helpful for dealing with kids that are blowing up from bug emotions. But I did find it less useful for the times they are just being an uncooperative little pill. But overall I found it was a good read for tempering expectations with the reality of brain development.

Martha H. Pieper, PhD

Excellent Application of Attachment Theory to Discipline

Reviewed in the United States on January 31, 2016

As the author of a parenting book that also advocates the necessity to discipline without damage (Smart Love: The Comprehenive Guide to Understanding, Regulating, and Enjoying Your Child) I am delighted to see a book that in theory and practice shows parents how to regulate their children's immature behaviors in constructive ways. This book is based on Attachment Theory and so the author emphasizes the importance of making connections and avoiding disconnection. There is another reason not to use so-called harmless methods of discipline, such as time-outs, rewards, and consequences, namely that children learn first and foremost by imitation and we do not want to model behaviors that we do not want them to adopt. For example, a time-out is certainly more benign than a spanking, but do we really want to teach children to distance themselves from others who are upset, unhappy, or angry. Even worse, they may learn to dislike themselves when they are upset or angry. If when we go to regulate our children's behavior we think, "Do I want my child to grow up to treat others this way?" we will be much more inclined to use the techniques advocated in this book.

Jennifer English

Easy read

Reviewed in the United States on March 6, 2024

Good ideas to assist parents.

Best Sellers in

Protocols: An Operating Manual for the Human Body

0 0

17.51

Forever Strong: A New, Science-Based Strategy for Aging Well

4.4 1229

17.05

The Balanced Brain: The Science of Mental Health

4.4 64

20.44

Fast Metabolism Food Rx: 7 Powerful Prescriptions to Feed Your Body Back to Health

4.5 492

15.75

The Salt Fix: Why Experts Got It All Wrong - and How Eating More Might Save Your Life

4.6 1974

23.54

Decolonizing Therapy: Oppression, Historical Trauma, and Politicizing Your Practice

4.7 89

18.8

Heart Minded: How to Hold Yourself and Others in Love

4.8 697

12.85

The Mosquito: A Human History of Our Deadliest Predator

4.4 990

21.66