Caution: This text is kind of “spoiler-ish”. It’s also kind of a rambling, more than a review. Per my usual style.
Whereas my comments for The Fixer explain why the book didn’t fully click with me until I read the second book, with Chaos Agent I experienced one of these incredible-read-rides that only happen every few months, and sometimes years.
This book is beyond intelligent, I mean way beyond, never mind an incredibly thrilling ride, this is called out as a romance, but allow me to call it a romantic blend with a very big side of (psychological) thriller.
As well, it is a masterful deep dive into the concept that was introduced in the first book regarding what is right and what is wrong, and just when the “on paper” wrong of something can be understandable and even acceptable, because life and feelings are a lot more complex than anything ever on paper.
This book helps us perhaps not forgive the horrible deeds of Michelle Hastings, but it certainly helps us understand where she’s coming from, what experiences (quite horrible, as well) made her do what she did. And for anyone that was still repulsed by all of those deeds, regardless –in other words, for anyone still firmly in the camp of right is right and wrong is wrong, I do believe the author found a freaking incredible way to “turn the tables” and make reluctant readers reflect – I personally think that was achieved with the “eye for an eye” event, pertaining not ‘just’ to Hastings but to the sweet and up to then very clearly sided on the “what’s right” camp Eden. I honestly think that is a masterful way to turn the tables on the staunchest supporters of the “what’s right is right and everything else is wrong” side. Turns out it did manage to turn the tables on the foremost representative of that view, Eden’s mom.
I so love the moral dilemmas this book presents, the ethical gray areas, and how they made me think. Love the fact Hastings is made accountable for her decisions, and is not entirely forgiven but sort of given a second chance (“you’re not in our supreme shit list anymore, just the regular shit list”), love the fact Eden (along with a host of readers, I would hope) comes to terms with the idea that someone is both capable of having done appalling things, but understanding what drove them there and understanding they do have a heart and a very caring nature to go with all the unsavory rest.
I am a huge fan of stories that shed light to the grayness of the world, to the fact nothing is entirely black or white, and I am exceptionally keen to read and debate on issues that force me to look at things from someone else’s shoes. This book? Big score on all this. This is not to say I condone unethical behavior as par for the course, but it is to say I do “get it” when things are not as clear cut as we’d like them to be. Almost nothing really ever is in real life. This book hits that spot so very well. And I reckon it took some very deep thinking from the author, because she started up with a character that nobody in world liked even a tiny bit, whose behavior in previous book appearances had made her almost Public Enemy #1.
Another factor that I appreciated very much is the fact that one of the side characters, and calling her side is painful for me because she really is a hugely important character to the plot of this book, doesn’t get any kind of what I call “Hollywood retribution”. That is only so very realistic that I could almost cry. As a matter of fact, it is a rather despicable character when one thinks about it, however I ended up pretty happy with the resolution of her arc. Again with the moral/ethical dilemmas. I’d put money on the fact many readers would have expected a different outcome for this character. I am exceedingly happy with the fact she ended up where she would most likely have ended up in real life. This character is also a testament to the cunning smarts all over this book. She outsmarts even Hastings. Enough said.
I ended up liking Hastings a lot more for her flaws than for any other traits –beauty, intelligence, power, the works. It’s a character that resounded with me as deeply human. From all the ice queens I’ve read in the last few years, most get to come relatively naked on the page about why they came to be the way they are – there is always a narrative to explain their backgrounds, but I don’t recall any other Ice Queen protagonist that gets treated like this one – exposing not only what made her strong, but especially what made her flawed, with the experiences that made her the woman she is, with her fears and consequent miserable behavior, not just what made them shine longer term, but what made her fall from grace to begin with. That is quite unique in this book.
It’s likely that Hastings doesn’t get “full pardon” from a good number of readers, but she surely gets to tell her side of the story, and for anyone that is empathetic she does come out quite redeemed on the other side. At least to me. Matter of fact, as I said earlier, she is deeply human in my view – she’s like the rest of us: essentially flawed, no super- human character, no perfection in sight.
I only have resounding applause for this book.
Chaos Agent: The Villains, Book 2
4.7
| 645 ratingsPrice: 18.8
Last update: 07-02-2024