This is a great book of the history of baseball with excellent stories over the last 120 years represented by the 100 players that the author highlights. Being an individual who enjoys reading about the older players, I was especially drawn to the stories about Alexander, Wagner, Cobb, Hornsby, Ruth, Foxx, Gehrig and Johnson. But, there are also excellent stories about the recent players if you like the recent baseball history. And, at the times, especially in the Mays and Ruth chapters, the writing is so good, it is almost poetic.
Then, though there is the ratings. Unlike Bill James who spends most of a chapter, pages and pages defining his tools and process of determining the ratings, this author uses less than one page rattling off a number of terms and then writing the following:
- Mariano Rivera is ranked 91 because of Psalm 91 (the protector psalm),
- Joe DiMaggio is ranked 56 because of 56 consecutive game hitting streak,
- Jackie Robinson is ranked 42 because that is his jersey number.
Robinson and DiMaggio should have been ranked in the top 20 and Mariano Rivera should have been higher. He was the only player to get 100% of the Hall of Fame to vote for him.
And, then there is the three PED players: Alex Rodriquez, Roger Clemens and Barry Bonds. They are all rated in the top 20 and because all of them cheated, they don't belong there. (Barry Bonds is actually ranked 3rd. Wrong.) In the Barry Bonds chapter, the author breaks the review into the people who think that Barry Bonds is great and those that despise him. I belong to neither. These three players belong in the top 100 but definitely not in the top 20.
If you are looking for a objective ranking, I recommend Bill James and after this book I still go by his rankings because they are not subjective or potentially biased like this book. His rankings of the top 10 are:
1. Babe Ruth
2. Honus Wagner
3. Willie Mays
4. Oscar Charleston
5. Ty Cobb
6. Mickey Mantle
7. Ted Williams
8. Walter Johnson
9. Josh Gibson
10. Stan Musial
I recommend this book for baseball history and stories. If you want an objective ranking, I recommend Bill James' books.