Based on a True Story: A Memoir
4.4 | 5,426 ratings
Price: 15.75
Last update: 12-30-2025
Top reviews from the United States
- TamyBuy the audio book!Get the audio book. Norm is the one reading it and I think its the best way to consume this book.
Ive seen some negative reviews and I’m a bit disappointed, as I thought this book perfectly incapsulates Norm and his humor. It was the best waste of time ever, as I thoroughly enjoyed how much Norm enjoyed writing this and probably laughing to himself, knowing he punked us one more time. It’s basically the story of his character with little openings that allow you to see real Norm.
Sure it’s not what most expect, but it’s Norm, and that’s exactly what I expected.
May you rest in peace, Norm MacDonald, and I will forever be grateful for your depth, wit and humor. Your tv appearances, podcasts, standups, etc. will continue to lead me out of dark places.
Once again, thank you Normy, you deeply closeted dead man. - Amazon CustomerPure Genius!!!ABSOLUTELY HILARIOUS!!!! Norm was the BEST!!!! When you read it you can actually hear his voice!!!
- Y. HomnickBeyond The Norm...To be truthful, I don't buy a lot of digital books. Usually, any book that doesn't help me reach a high shelf, or can't be used to swat a fly on the wall, isn't multi-purpose enough for my medieval mindset.
But Norm MacDonald is Norm MacDonald is Norm MacDonald, and I wanted a copy at 12:01a.m. of its release date. I also wanted to save the tree that would've been used to print this book so that the tree could be used for its most natural purpose: Baseball bats. Or exacerbating forest fires. (Take that, Smokey, you overgrown, smarmy, preachy Ursus Americanus!)
As one of Norm's slavish Twitter followers, I tweeted that I would be counting my audible laughs, divide them by the purchase price, and determine whether I got good value from my purchase. While I haven't finished counting the marks on my wall, and add the fact that I was forced to stop marking the wall by a wife who under-appreciates Jail Cell-style decor, I can only give you a rough range on this. I surmise that each laugh cost slightly under two cents. Even if you count belly laughs as worth a dime, and short,snorting laughs as being worth a penny, I got good value from this tome.
And whether my purchase amount helps him recover from his last gambling flame-out, or helps fund his next downward spiral, I figure I contributed to a Good Cause.
But, I didn't buy this book just for laughs, or to take credit for fueling the MacDonald Publishing Empire. I wanted to get a glimpse into one of the most original, brilliant comedic minds of our time. In that capacity, Norm opened a small window into his soul... then slammed it closed on my fingers.
First, my view of Norm: Most comedians come from ethnic groups that are held down artificially, or had harrowing childhoods, or are introspective to the point of self-flagellation. Norm, by contrast, seems to be a cheery, boyishly handsome, middle-class Caucasian with an impish quality to him. And Canadian, to boot. From where comes the compulsion to make us laugh?
On top of that, he has a strong anti-establishment streak, and a refusal to be controlled. "Big deal," you say, "So do I!" Norm differs in that his unwillingness to be controlled includes the people that sign his checks, or that could lift him onto the next step of the success ladder. And for some reason, Bosses tend not to hire unpredictable Free Spirits that may defy direct orders on a whim - even if they're excellent at what they due. Check Signers like predictability, period.
So, when you continue to make witheringly effective O.J. jokes while working under one of O.J.'s friends & golf partners, or when you're asked to be "shocking" at a roast of Bob Saget and you therefore write one cornball line from the 1950's after another, it makes TV producers skittish about giving you a late-night talk show, for example. So, while that level of subversion & unpredictability adds to his legend, it commensurately subtracts from his potential income.
Yet, Norm protests that he'd rather be a high-profile comic than a "comic's comic", a commercially successful comedian than a critically acclaimed one. So, I wonder out loud from where the dissonance stems.
Norm hints that he might have been repeatedly sexually abused as a boy. But, since this is only "BASED ON a True Story", he leaves you wondering: Was this a literary device to introduce another of many writing styles he uses throughout the book? Or was this a way of explaining why he never wants to feel "totally out of control" in his life again? Was this a comedic device to make an anti-joke when you were expecting a joke? Or was this a way to connect to his readers with a deeply personal admission? Was this an attempt to exploit another taboo subject for devastating comic effect - as he has with prison rape, media treatment of murders, gay pride, Hitler, bestiality, psychopathic sadists, etc.? Or is this the exposing of one of the roots of his addictive personality?
We'll never know. Norm has recently bristled at this book being referred to in the media as a memoir, when in his mind he wrote a novel. Mind you, a memoir is not synonymous with an autobiography. A memoir allows for a greater exchange of Truth for truthiness. And novels generally don't use real people's names, especially real people who have lawyers on retainer.
So, if you want to read a funny, entertaining, quirky & unique book, it's a 5. If you want to read about Norm's life, it's a 2. If you want to read Alice In Wonderland with a male lead, and where the mind-altering substances are addiction and gambling, it's a 3.5.
Stop reading this, and buy the stupid book already. It's still more real than that frappuccino you were going to spend the money on, and it'll keep you awake at least as well. And while you're at it, re-watch Norm's Dirty Work, disregarding the poor pacing and below-par acting. There's still comic gold to be mined in them thar celluloid hills. - AlexaTrue, Not true?It’s hard to know what information is true and what is not in this unique novel. It doesn’t really matter. Funny and tragic it explains some of what you see in this author’s on camera work. He’s a comic genius who doesn’t appeal to all. He is mesmerizing to watch. I can’t stop watching his appearances across his professional life. Professor of Logic he is not, but his ability to entertain, with humor, like no other is pure enjoyment. His development both personally and professionally is fascinating to watch. I hope to go to the University of Science some day. I particularly enjoyed hearing his voice as he read this tale. It also freed up my hands so I could eat my cheese sandwich. If you are unfamiliar with my Norm, please dial him up on YouTube and watch his appearances on Letterman who he idolized, Conan who I had never watched before, his bold and brave material from Weekend Update on SNL and his stand-up appearances which are legend to us in the know. From a beginning comic, who told about his life experiences with that boyish naiveté and genuine surprise at how life works is a treasure to watch over and over and then seeing him in each new decade is a gift I am grateful for. Thinking about Janice with bangs kills me every time. They’ll find her!”
- TT69Norm MacDonald has been my favorite comedian ever since I saw him live at the ...Norm MacDonald has been my favorite comedian ever since I saw him live at the Hollywood Improv Comedy Club in December of 1991. I’ll never forget the joke he told about riding in the backseat of a car where he was so out of the conversation with the people in the front that he started communicating with people in the backseats of other cars! Norm was the first person in L.A. I could identify with and he had a similar sense of humor as me. I knew he was going to make it big and when I saw him on SNL I was extremely happy!!! I was also extremely pissed when he got fired for “not being funny” because his fake news segment was the funniest thing about the show.
As for his book, I was excited to read it, but lost interest half way through and haven’t finished it yet. What threw me was his veering off into fantasy by telling a story of accompanying a boy to fulfill his wish of clubbing a baby seal to death. It’s not funny. Some of the other fictional stuff he tells about his sidekick Adam Eget isn’t funny either....it’s too dark. I can appreciate black comedy, but only when it’s funny.
I’ve heard Norm mention in interviews that he reads a lot of Tolstoy, and that he’s his favorite author. It shows as his book seems Tolystoyesque at times. Tolstoy is not funny, insightful about the human condition, but not funny. Perhaps Norm is just showing his intelligence and depth by not focusing on being funny all the time, or perhaps his comedy has gotten so intellectually deep that I can longer comprehend it.
Whatever the case may be, there are enough interesting stories, details and humor that I plan to finish the book sometime in the near future. Norm is my favorite comedian and I’m glad he shared his story with the world.