The black one would have gotten 5 stars for me as it hung perfectly across stomach, hit about mid hip and was super soft, was an XL. Then I ordered same shirt in blue, same size and like a dummy, I threw away pkging and clipped off tag without trying it on first. When I put it on yesterday, I realized it was incredibly too big compared to the black one. This dragged all the way to thighs and arms were ridiculously too long. I took pictures of both on same hanger so you can see the difference. I can't return the blue one now and I currently have it in high heat dryer trying to shrink it down. Just when you think you can buy the same thing in same size, diff color without trying it on, you can't. I've had this happen twice recently with clothes from Amazon but luckily with previous one, I tried it on first. This one's one me but be aware the blue one is either mislabeled for size or horrifically stretched out. I ordered the Large and it was exact measurements of the XL..long and stretched out. Insane that I will need a Medium in the blue when I need XL in the black of the same exact shirt