This book makes me want to know more about the extremely interesting Belle Greene. Turning to the current Wikipedia article about her, I find… exactly the same information, maybe minus her tendency to get drunk at parties. But still, kudos to the authors for shining a light on Belle. Five stars for that.
Turning to the reading experience, then, where to begin? The prose and imagery screams YA. It’s been bunged down on the page using completely current vernacular, with concepts and turns of phrase that nobody in 1910 America would have been using, and lots of moony, nonspecific, romantic Thoughts About Boys. Anyone who loves the Paper Magician books will feel right at home. Always a good idea when you are trying to make a historical period accessible to pre-teens, so I’d still recommend this book unreservedly to them. And for the rest of us, there’s no reason to go to the other extreme and try to imitate the Edwardians. So it’s ok, and readable enough, better than a cereal box. But two stars off. Wait until you can check it out for free.